Current Conditions

Showing posts with label congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label congress. Show all posts

Thursday, February 19, 2026

NoCapFund: Why do we have 435 members in the House of Representatives?

 I had to attributed this to another YouTube channel - No Cap Fund - because I don't want to see this blog go on a Mr. Beat overload. He had talked about this in the past and have one video to show about it.

Mr. Beat wants to uncap the number of members in the US House of Representatives and he goes through the history of apportionment of representatives. Uncapping the number of representatives doesn't involve a constitutional amendment, it involves an act of Congress.

Mr. Beat has been attempting to get his congressman to take a stand on this issue although it appears a candidate for Congress is willing to take this issue on. And also it appears an Illinois Congresman Sean Casten seems ready to take on this issue as discussed in a live stream.

Here's the most recent video on this topic that Mr. Beat made [VIDEO]


My position on this is ambiguous. 

I can believe as stated in this video that polarization is a very serious thing that's worth putting a damper on. Does this necessarily mean more representatives? Does this mean a far more ideologically diverse representatives?

I do like the idea of bringing down the number of people in each district. Say perhaps instead of the 800K population per district we instead create more districts that perhaps could be about half that or less. 

Another thing noted is that if you mess with the number of representatives, you may also mess with the Electoral College count - now that's in the constitution (electoral votes are no. of representatives + Senators). Perhaps this means a recalcuation of the Electoral College math.

How could I sell this for say minority districts perhaps this might mean it would be easier in this state at least to create districts for Hispanics, Blacks, and others depending on where they may reside. I want to eliminate gerrymandering and who knows if this may address that. However, the states control drawing congressional maps more than the federal gov't does.

I think this is worth a discussion as opposed to killing this because reflexively we may decide there shouldn't be more politicians. Should we have more than 435 representatives? What do you think?

Monday, August 25, 2025

The Recount: Why Expanding Congress Would End Gerrymandering

 Gerrymandering has been in the news lately. Texas recently approved a mid-decade redistricting plan thought not without controversy and states like Illinois and California are looking at creating their own plan. The ongoing controversy is partisan in practice with Republicans assuring they remain in control of the house while Democrats want to insure their own political power.

With this said when you watch the video below, consider this video I posted last year from Mr. Beat where there is an argument to expand the US House of Representatives. Let's add to this the possibility of using proportional representation that insures minority parties doesn't get shut out.

Most other nations on the globe either elect their legislatures this way or at least form their governments via proportional representation. And with this to work to determine members of the US House of Representatives what might help this along is expanding the members of the House as Mr. Beat discusses.

First watch the video [VIDEO]


IMHO, I think we do need to expand the number of Congresspersons (hey I like that better than Alderperson). I'm not entirely sold on proportional representation, but let's talk about it. We could expand this to state legislatures or even city councils (mostly big cities).

However, let's bear in mind this video is starting off talking about gerrymandering. The question is about creating fair maps.

Iowa is showing creating maps that largely considers county boundaries. Also why is there gerrymandering? These are districts drawn with political considerations and from what I know about redistricting in Illinois for example, it's to ensure that politicians get to retain their seats or more accurately to ensure politicians get to maintain their constituencies.

That means sometimes in other states outside of Iowa, cities might get split up between different districts. An example of Massachusetts the point was made that to ensure there is a Republican district there is to create a heavily gerrymandered map to elect one Republican there to Congress. Massachusetts was said to have voted 36% for Republican Donald Trump in 2024 for President, however, all Congresspersons elected from there are Democrats.

Has this video educated you on gerrymandering? Do you think we need to change how we draw our districts?

Monday, July 29, 2024

Mr. Beat: Why are there only 435 members in the U.S. House of Representatives?

 

[VIDEO] Let's start with this, the number of Representatives in the lower house of Congress is set by statute the Permanent Apportionment Act of 1929. Check out this apportionment sheet from visitthecapitol.gov

In the beginning when the nation only had 13 states - 13 colonies, 13 states - the expectation was 1 Representative for every 30,000 citizen. Of course now America is about 300 million people since the constitution was enacted in 1789. 

America's population has grown and the point of this recent video by Mr. Beat is that the number of representatives doesn't represent the vast population of this nation and perhaps we need a lot more than 435 members of the U.S. House of Reps. 

Another part of this argument is that the bureaucracy has grown to the point that many executive agencies have taken on some duties that would normally be taken up by the US Congress - both houses. To increase the number of representatives would probably allow the Congress to function the way it was designed to.

Here's a website called No Cap Fund that advocates for increasing the number of Representives in Congress.

And just for the record the number of US Senators is 100. Two per state, regardless of population while the U.S. House the number of Representatives each state has is determined by population. Which is why some states lose Representatives while other states gain Representatives. If your state drops in population as Illinois had in 2020 that that extra representative gets sent to another state.

I would say states that grow in population which would I would say are such states such as Texas, Florida, Georgia to name a few off the top of my head. They would gain more representatives from those states which have lost population.

Having watch this video or even read up on this subject do you think there needs to be more Representatives in the US Congress?

Saturday, April 1, 2023

Mr. Beat: Every impeachment in American history

 

[VIDEO] Mr. Beat - hopefully your favorite ed-u-tuber - takes on this civic/political topic of impeachment. The relevant part of this process you can find in the US Constitution.

As you will see three presidents have been impeached and all have been acquitted. Trump is the only president to have been impeached twice and in the second case he was impeached just as he was leaving office due to his alleged role in inciting the January 6, 2021 insurrection. And one driver of this was to make him ineligible for running again for president in 2024.

In addition to three presidents - Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and Donald Trump. The other federal officials who were impeached were a US Senator, cabinet officials, a US Supreme Court Justice, and federal judges. Some were removed from their office and in some cases were ineligible to hold any federal office.

They noted that usually for impeachment hearings the House would hold investigative committees and then they would have a vote for impeachment. Then a trial in the Senate which would determine whether or not to convict the impeached party. Basically the House is the grand jury and the Senate is the jury.

Now also note that the process is meant to be political, perhaps a mechanism to remove someone who at the very least isn't operating within the bounds of the Constitution. What helps this process is whether or not there were actual criminal charges against the official. In most cases noted in this video there were criminal charges that lead to impeachment.

Monday, May 16, 2022

Mr. Beat: I called every U.S. Senator in the country. Here were the responses I got.

 

[VIDEO] Mr. Beat in two livestreams contacted all 50 U.S. Senators and the President of the Senate who is also Vice President Kamala Harris. He never talked to a Senator got a video message from one, got more or less chain messages from at least a couple. Got one response lecturing him on instant runoff voting. However not even a quarter of all U.S. Senators responded to him.

Some staffers were uncomfortable with being recorded. Some have heard of Mr. Beat. Others seemed underwhelmed and not very interested in what Mr. Beat was calling about. A few stated that they're only recording comments for constituents from their respective states.

And as for that last statement I wonder how they do treat their own constituents. Mr. Beat could conclude that the U.S. Senate offices are probably more into the opinions of special interests and lobbyists than the voter. 

Has anyone out there contacted their elected representatives?

Tuesday, February 1, 2022

Livestream Pt. 2: Mr. Beat calls every U.S. Senator

 

[VIDEO] I believe this started at 9:00 AM this morning and as I write this at 10:32 AM he's still going. So far he's contacted U.S. Senators from Montana and I as write this Mr. Beat contacted New York Democrat U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand. Sorry go for part one if you want to see him contact Illinois' U.S. Senators.

This should be a fun exercise as far as contacting your elected representatives. 

Saturday, January 22, 2022

Mr. Beat discusses the U.S. Senate filibuster

 

[VIDEO] I admitted not that long ago that I used to watch C-Span and watched sessions of the U.S. Senate and got a somewhat easy grasp of the lingo though not of the rules that govern that given chamber. And then we hear about the filibuster which we see some politicians mostly Democrats as of late want to eliminate that as a tactic to stop any bill/legislation in their tracks.

Mr. Beat view the filibuster rule as a way the U.S. Senate isn'tt able to get much work done which is to pass laws/legislation at least in tandem with the U.S. House of Representatives. Whom I don't believe have the filibuster and of course have their own rules that govern that chamber.

So here's your education on the filibuster, and without having ever served in the Senate - yes I'm old enough to do so being over 30 and I also have to win an election to do so - I can't say I have a real opinion on the filibuster. Perhaps I'm not big and just changing rules or procedures for no good reason beyond it makes political sense. I could believe that the minority in the Senate should have their own means to have their voice heard and killing a filibuster could hurt that.

Anyway since the filibuster has been in the political news as of late - and with the added race issue being its use in attempting to kill civil rights legislation - I hope you learn something new with this.

Monday, October 18, 2021

Let's talk about Illinois' congressional remap

While this is old news I'm very happy to share this video from Let's Talk Elections on YouTube. You may have seen him in a video from Mr. Beat where they "handicap" the 2020 presidential race where they predicted - correctly :( - that Joe Biden will be the next POTUS. 


[VIDEO] In this video Ethan talks about the congressional redistricting that dropped on Friday. Every 10 years the US gov't conducts a census and that census helps to determine the number of representatives in each state and Illinois lost one Congressional seat. Of course Illinois wasn't the only one to lose  congressional seats. Of all places California has lost a congressional seat, I mean really the most populous state in our union.

Either way if you want to know more about the situation in Illinois check out Capitol Fax. This is said to be a first draft map and the map is drawn to favor Democrats. Democrats already hold a majority of the congressional seats in this state. Now whether or not this may help Democrats retain their hold on the U.S. House of Representatives in the 2022 midterms remains to be seen.

The draft map that I saw just strikes me as very gerrymandered. Of course gerrymandering is a way that a political party in general tries to maintain their advantage utilizing the mapmaking process. We're talking about congressional seats right now, this could be done for state legislative seats or even for Chicago city council wards. In processes like this that can become heavily political expect there to be challenges. Of course the map as you would see in the above video could stand once some tweaks are made.

Aside from political advantage, another reason for gerrymandering is to ensure that a particular political map will elect certain minorities. For example the 4th Congressional District in Illinois has historically been drawn in such a way to ensure the election of a Latino U.S. Representative. On the local level in addition to maintaining a balance between Black, white and Latino wards there are calls to create a ward to ensure the representation and election of an Asian to the Chicago City Council.

Either way perhaps I will share any further updates here about the Congressional redistricting here at the "Shedd School of Political Science".

Thursday, February 6, 2020

Impeachment over

[VIDEO] I'm sorry to have not followed this as consistently as I should've, however, the result of this wasn't exactly in doubt. No more than the confusion that occurred in Monday's Iowa Caucuses.

So this happened yesterday...
The Senate voted Wednesday to acquit President Trump on charges of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, ending a historic Senate trial that was centered on his conduct toward Ukraine but that did not include live witnesses or new documents.

One Republican — Sen. Mitt Romney of Utah — crossed party lines to join Democrats in voting to convict Trump on the first charge, abuse of power.

Trump stonewalled the House impeachment probe, blocking witnesses and denying documents. He stands as the third president to be impeached.

The acquittal follows a State of the Union address Tuesday night in which Trump pointed to the strong economy as vindication as he sought to move on from impeachment. The speech ended with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) tearing up a copy of Trump’s prepared remarks.

The crux of the case against Trump is the allegation that he withheld military aid and a White House meeting to pressure Ukraine to investigate Joe Biden and his son. Hunter Biden served on the board of Burisma, a Ukrainian energy company, while his father was vice president.
It's no surprise that there are many in Washington, DC who doesn't like President Donald Trump. He's unlike anyone else who became President in recently memory. I'm glad the impeachment vote resulted in acquittal and we can get on with the business of this country.

With that said, I know many were unhappy with the results of an election that took place just about four years ago. Remember that this year in 2020, we're going through an election season that started in Iowa. By the summer we'll know who will be the Democrat nominee for President.

Still, we do have an election this year. I would encourage you to pick a candidate and if you got people in other states encourage them to vote for the candidate of your choice. If you don't like our current President, we have the opportunity to fix that later this year!